| Object | Description | Attribution | Owner | Provenance Trail |
| Bed | Walnut spool bed | Petersen House | CHS | William Petersen heirs to William H. Boyd to Andrew Boyd to Charles Gunther |
| Brush | Wooden brush with natural bristles | Abraham Lincoln | CHS | Mary Todd Lincoln to Elizabeth Keckly to Lowdermilk & Co. to Charles Gunther |
| Cloak | Black velvet woman's cloak, c. 1860s | Mary Todd Lincoln | CHS | Mary Todd Lincoln to Elizabeth Keckly to Lowdermilk & Co. to Charles Gunther |
| Cloth fragment | White silk | Clara Harris | CHS | Thomas Pendel to Josephine Brodie Chester |
| Cloth fragment | Corded silk with ikat flower print | Laura Keene | CHS | Laura Keene to Emma Eliza Taylor Rawsore to Mrs. William McLaire to Mrs. R.E. Peacock |
| Cloth fragment | Man's black frock coat, c. 1860s | Abraham Lincoln | CHS | Edward Payson Hammond to H.P. Main |
| Cloth fragment | Woven toweling | Petersen House | CHS | B.F. Weischampel to Charles Gunther |
| Cloth fragment | Woven toweling; in frame | Petersen House | CHS | Fred Petersen to W.S. Kaufman to Charles Gunther |
| Cloth fragment | Black wool attributed to coat | Abraham Lincoln | CHS | Unknown |
| Cloth fragment | Black silk with white tulip print | Mary Todd Lincoln | CHS | Mary Todd Lincoln to Elizabeth Keckly to Lowdermilk & Co. to Charles Gunther |
| Cloth fragment | White silk; in frame | Clara Harris | CHS | Unknown |
| Coat | Man's frock coat of black broadcloth with quilted black silk lining | Abraham Lincoln | CHS | Mary Todd Lincoln to Thomas Pendel to Frank Logan |
| Coins | Two silver half-dollars laid on Lincoln's eyes, dated 1854 and 1861 | Abraham Lincoln | CHS | George V. Rutherford to Charles Gunther (?) |
| Comb | Black rubber comb | Abraham Lincoln | CHS | Mary Todd Lincoln to Elizabeth Keckly to Charles Gunther |
| Flag | U.S. flag | Abraham Lincoln | CHS | William Brearley to heirs to Charles Gunther |
| Hair | Lock of hair; in U.S. Clothing Depot envelope | Abraham Lincoln | CHS | William Brearley to heirs to Charles Gunther |
| Hair | Lock of hair; in frame | Abraham Lincoln | CHS | Unknown to Ann Todd Smith to Frank Munson to heirs |
| Hair | Lock of hair; with note testifying it was taken from near A. Lincoln's bullet wound | Abraham Lincoln | CHS | Unknown to Charles Gunther (?) |
| Hair | Strands of hair; in gold locket | Abraham Lincoln | CHS | Surgeon General Barnes to Thomas Pendel to Frank Logan |
| Hood | Brown canvas padded hood with heavy twine lacings | Lewis Powell (Paine) | CHS | William Brearley to Charles Gunther |
| Keys | Five keys; numbered 01, 04, 13, 16, 10 | Ford's Theatre | CHS | Unknown to Charles Gunther |
| Mattress | Corn husk mattress manufactured by J.M. Curran's Mattress Factory Washington, DC | Petersen House | CHS | William Petersen heirs to William H. Boyd to Andrew Boyd to Charles Gunther |
| Pillow | Feather bolster pillow | Petersen House | CHS | Louise Petersen Rector to heirs |
| Sheet | Bed sheet | Petersen House | CHS | Thomas Thompson to Samuel Bridge to Charles Gunther |
| Shirt sleeve | Sleeve of man's undershirt | Abraham Lincoln | CHS | William Brearley to heirs to Charles Gunther |
| Wallpaper | Paper scrap with green, mustard, orange, and cream striped pattern | Petersen House | CHS | Unknown to Mrs. Willis J. Shockey |
| Wallpaper | Paper scrap with red background and red sprig design of three oak leaves | Ford's Theatre | CHS | Unknown |
| Wood fragment | Fragment of floorboard | Petersen House | CHS | Unknown |
| Wood fragment | Gilt wood molding | Ford's Theatre | CHS | Unknown to Charles Gunther |